NFL, producers concur there is no ideal helmet
Green Bay Packers Jerseys Onlineshop webeditor report:
As Philadelphia Eagles receiver DeSean Jackson(notes) prepared to come back lastweekend from his 2nd concussion in under a year, he was supplied a special,new helmet. even however he hoped being better protected, the helmet's maker certainlywouldn't—and couldn't—guarantee Jackson will almost certainly be completely safe and audio tracks from braininjuries.
The truth is, no helmet can offer you that kind of complete safeguard in theNFL, wherever there is an common of 1 1/2 to two concussions in just about every game.
In a sequence of interviews using the connected Press, representatives of theNFL, its players' union and also the 4 items companies that make just about every helmetworn inside of the league all agreed there is no hockey helmet—in development or ondrawing boards—that can eradicate concussions. And there might never be one.
Graphic describes what happens… AP - Nov 12, 1:16 pm EST information file - This Nov. 7, 2010, file… AP - Nov 12, 11:24 am EST information file - This Oct. 17, 2010, fil… AP - Nov 12, 11:22 am EST
* 1 of 3
* NFL Gallery AdChoices
The NFL acknowledges the realism that deficiency of a ideal helmet contributed to itsdecision in current weeks to make full use of hefty fines and also the risk of suspensions to cutdown on hazardous hits. It's also why the league's head, neck and spine medicalcommittee is holding a two-day getting together with up arriving month to seem into new methods to testand design and type helmets.
"A concussion-proof helmet? So far, there is practically nothing to that effect," saidRay Anderson, the NFL's executive vice president of hockey operations. "Idon't know if (manufacturers) could ever convince us or assure us that your helmetthat would completely avoid concussions is doable. I haven't noticed this kind of athing."
appropriate now, the helmet makers know they cannot make this kind of claims.
"I do not believe there'll ever be whatever that is a concussion-proof footballhelmet. i have noticed that phrase thrown around, but inside of the helmet world, withtoday's technology, that is not achievable," described Thad Ide, vice president ofresearch and advancement at Riddell.
"It's essential to recognize that there is a limit to just how much helmets cando," Ide continued. "And player behavior, player education, strategies changes—all of those factors may have as much, or more, of a benefit in reducing the riskof concussion."
Helmets used inside of the NFL—and NCAA or better school football, for that matter— are designed to pass a check originated via the nationwide working Committee onStandards for Athletic items (NOCSAE), a nonprofit corporation. The group'swebsite information that it establishes "voluntary check standards," that"manufacturers check their really own helmets" understanding that "NOCSAE does not own asurveillance drive to make certain compliance using the standards."
The screening method founded inside of the 1970s continues to be fundamentally the sametoday. The objective then was to stop sudden death, skull fractures and brainbleeding in football—not stop concussions because they are defined now—andthere's universal agreement that objective may be achieved. But NOCSAE states itwould want to understand a treatment to upgrade the typical and screening to better accountfor concussions, as quickly as substantially more is known about the causes that cause them.
"We cannot create a change to our typical until, No. 1, we know it's title tobe beneficial, and No. 2, the realism that change that individuals would include wouldn'tmake the sleep using the typical less protective or even the realism that change wouldn'tincrease the risk of damage within an additional area," executive director Mike Oliversaid. "Science does not know the answer."
Concussions happen when the brain moves within the skull from an influence or awhiplash effect. Some assess it to the motion of a yolk inside of a shell if anegg were tossed faraway from a window—yes, wrapping the egg in bubble-wrap mightkeep the shell from cracking, nonetheless it wouldn't stop the yolk from jostling.
"I do not believe that is a several arranged of problems than car manufacturersface when building refreshing air bags or car seats for children," Schutt Sportspresident and CEO Robert Erb said.
"I cannot contain the helmet weigh too much, credited to then I'm placing stressloads on the neck and I'm making a full arranged of several problems. I can'tput in a huge amount of padding, credited to then I'm making a heat-related issue. I can'tmake it too thin. I cannot ensure it is too thick," described Erb, whose organisation madeJackson's old and new helmets.
tag Lovell, founding director using the school of Pittsburgh MedicalCenter sporting activities medication Concussion Program, described a concussion-proof helmet is not"a practical goal, credited for you cannot arranged a helmet on the brain."
"The helmet sits on the skull, and also the brain moves within the skull, andthat's actually what prospects to the concussion," described Lovell, who has served as aconsultant to the NFL too as other main sporting activities leagues.
Factors that perform into whether or not concussions hold place include whether or not a playertook previous hits to the mind that day; how hydrated he is; wherever on the helmethe receives hit; whether or not the player noticed the strike arriving and was able to tense neckmuscles so his mind spins less violently.
and also the list goes on.
"I do not personally think, in my really own mind, the helmet is ever title to bethe treatment to concussions. But I believe they need being made better inside of the future,just such as the current kinds are created better than they were inside of the past," saidDr. Robert Cantu, a medical professor of neurosurgery in the Boston UniversitySchool of Medicine, senior adviser to the NFL's concussion committee and NOCSAEvice president.
The NFL's Anderson described it's "exactly right" to generate a connection betweenthe current point out of helmet solutions and also the efforts via the league to increaseenforcement of strategies governing illegal hits to the head, this kind of as fines of upto $75,000.
"It's really apparent that donning a helmet, in and of itself, is not protectingour men from concussions too as other trauma," described Anderson, who can make initialdecisions on punishment for NFL safety-rule violations, "so to the extent thatwe can perform substantially more by aggressively enforcing our strategies and acquiring illegaltechniques and hits to the mind out using the game, we've an obligation to dothat."
The NFL and NFLPA concussion committees, helmet makers, the division ofDefense and leading experts will participate in discussions Dec. 8-9 to:examine whether or not one can find new supplies that could improve helmets; establish ifsensors need being utilized in helmets, mouthguards or earpieces donned by NFL playersto measure results of various types of hits to the head; evaluation the NFL'sreturn-to-play strategies founded in December 2009, this kind of as consideringwhether sideline checks used to establish if a player carries a concussion need to bestandardized so just about every group employs the same, mandated neurological exam.
"We're turning all over just about every stone you might imagine," described RichardEllenbogen, chairman using the school of Washington health care school's departmentof neurological surgical methods and co-chair using the NFL's head, neck and spine medicalcommittee.
The NFL states it's obtained invested $10 , 000, 000 on the concern contemplating about 2006, including$6 , 000, 000 on concussion- and helmet-related exploration and education.
"We certainly will not acquire a helmet that decreases concussions," described ThomMayer, health care director for that players' union, "unless we try."
The helmet makers say they are trying.
Boston University's Cantu quickly rattled away developments this kind of as Riddell'sincreased width, Schutt's new cushioning materials, and what he called Xenith's"rather dramatic" change from typical foams to air-cell padding insidehelmets.
No make a difference what breakthroughs have are available about, some NFL players soundskeptical about just just how much safeguard helmets can provide.
"They're generating tons of several designs of helmets, and I put on the old,traditional style. I kind of feel, like, if you are title to get knocked out,you're title to get knocked out," Indianapolis Colts cornerback Jerraud Powers(notes)said. "I do not actually believe the helmet issues when it arrives for you owning aconcussion or not."
described Pittsburgh Steelers protection Troy Polamalu(notes): "I've noticed players try outthe new helmets, get concussions and say, ‘I'm title back once more to the old one."'
just about every player is permitted to pick which brand he wears. The NFL estimatesthat 75 percent of helmets used this year or so are created by Riddell, which has experienced alicensing/sponsorship agreement using the league contemplating about 1990; 23 percent are madeby Schutt, 1 to some few of percent by Xenith, including a handful by Adams USA. Rawlings, whichstopped generating hockey helmets substantially greater than two decades ago, is returning to thebusiness in 2011 and has partnered using the Cleveland Clinic for concussionresearch.
based on Schutt, Eagles expert Bowler Jackson experienced been donning one certain of itshelmet versions that went faraway from development about two many years ago. Then came Oct.17, a Sunday filled with some especially vicious hits across the NFL,including the shot Jackson took from Atlanta Falcons cornerback Dunta Robinson(notes)that still left both males on the ground, motionless. Jackson and Robinson both ended upwith concussions; just about every missed his team's up arriving game; Robinson appealed the$50,000 good levied via the league for that hit.
D.J. MacLean, Schutt's director of sporting activities marketing, traveled toPhiladelphia final 1 week to examine on Jackson and his new helmet—outfitted,unlike his old Schutt, owning a materials the organisation states does a much better jobof withstanding impacts.
"A great offer substantially more cushioning. It felt good," Jackson described Friday following practice."I'll surely utilize it again."
Still, MacLean will almost certainly be the 1st to inform you, that materials cannot ensurethose effects do not cause concussions.
As Philadelphia Eagles receiver DeSean Jackson(notes) prepared to come back lastweekend from his 2nd concussion in under a year, he was supplied a special,new helmet. even however he hoped being better protected, the helmet's maker certainlywouldn't—and couldn't—guarantee Jackson will almost certainly be completely safe and audio tracks from braininjuries.
The truth is, no helmet can offer you that kind of complete safeguard in theNFL, wherever there is an common of 1 1/2 to two concussions in just about every game.
In a sequence of interviews using the connected Press, representatives of theNFL, its players' union and also the 4 items companies that make just about every helmetworn inside of the league all agreed there is no hockey helmet—in development or ondrawing boards—that can eradicate concussions. And there might never be one.
Graphic describes what happens… AP - Nov 12, 1:16 pm EST information file - This Nov. 7, 2010, file… AP - Nov 12, 11:24 am EST information file - This Oct. 17, 2010, fil… AP - Nov 12, 11:22 am EST
* 1 of 3
* NFL Gallery AdChoices
The NFL acknowledges the realism that deficiency of a ideal helmet contributed to itsdecision in current weeks to make full use of hefty fines and also the risk of suspensions to cutdown on hazardous hits. It's also why the league's head, neck and spine medicalcommittee is holding a two-day getting together with up arriving month to seem into new methods to testand design and type helmets.
"A concussion-proof helmet? So far, there is practically nothing to that effect," saidRay Anderson, the NFL's executive vice president of hockey operations. "Idon't know if (manufacturers) could ever convince us or assure us that your helmetthat would completely avoid concussions is doable. I haven't noticed this kind of athing."
appropriate now, the helmet makers know they cannot make this kind of claims.
"I do not believe there'll ever be whatever that is a concussion-proof footballhelmet. i have noticed that phrase thrown around, but inside of the helmet world, withtoday's technology, that is not achievable," described Thad Ide, vice president ofresearch and advancement at Riddell.
"It's essential to recognize that there is a limit to just how much helmets cando," Ide continued. "And player behavior, player education, strategies changes—all of those factors may have as much, or more, of a benefit in reducing the riskof concussion."
Helmets used inside of the NFL—and NCAA or better school football, for that matter— are designed to pass a check originated via the nationwide working Committee onStandards for Athletic items (NOCSAE), a nonprofit corporation. The group'swebsite information that it establishes "voluntary check standards," that"manufacturers check their really own helmets" understanding that "NOCSAE does not own asurveillance drive to make certain compliance using the standards."
The screening method founded inside of the 1970s continues to be fundamentally the sametoday. The objective then was to stop sudden death, skull fractures and brainbleeding in football—not stop concussions because they are defined now—andthere's universal agreement that objective may be achieved. But NOCSAE states itwould want to understand a treatment to upgrade the typical and screening to better accountfor concussions, as quickly as substantially more is known about the causes that cause them.
"We cannot create a change to our typical until, No. 1, we know it's title tobe beneficial, and No. 2, the realism that change that individuals would include wouldn'tmake the sleep using the typical less protective or even the realism that change wouldn'tincrease the risk of damage within an additional area," executive director Mike Oliversaid. "Science does not know the answer."
Concussions happen when the brain moves within the skull from an influence or awhiplash effect. Some assess it to the motion of a yolk inside of a shell if anegg were tossed faraway from a window—yes, wrapping the egg in bubble-wrap mightkeep the shell from cracking, nonetheless it wouldn't stop the yolk from jostling.
"I do not believe that is a several arranged of problems than car manufacturersface when building refreshing air bags or car seats for children," Schutt Sportspresident and CEO Robert Erb said.
"I cannot contain the helmet weigh too much, credited to then I'm placing stressloads on the neck and I'm making a full arranged of several problems. I can'tput in a huge amount of padding, credited to then I'm making a heat-related issue. I can'tmake it too thin. I cannot ensure it is too thick," described Erb, whose organisation madeJackson's old and new helmets.
tag Lovell, founding director using the school of Pittsburgh MedicalCenter sporting activities medication Concussion Program, described a concussion-proof helmet is not"a practical goal, credited for you cannot arranged a helmet on the brain."
"The helmet sits on the skull, and also the brain moves within the skull, andthat's actually what prospects to the concussion," described Lovell, who has served as aconsultant to the NFL too as other main sporting activities leagues.
Factors that perform into whether or not concussions hold place include whether or not a playertook previous hits to the mind that day; how hydrated he is; wherever on the helmethe receives hit; whether or not the player noticed the strike arriving and was able to tense neckmuscles so his mind spins less violently.
and also the list goes on.
"I do not personally think, in my really own mind, the helmet is ever title to bethe treatment to concussions. But I believe they need being made better inside of the future,just such as the current kinds are created better than they were inside of the past," saidDr. Robert Cantu, a medical professor of neurosurgery in the Boston UniversitySchool of Medicine, senior adviser to the NFL's concussion committee and NOCSAEvice president.
The NFL's Anderson described it's "exactly right" to generate a connection betweenthe current point out of helmet solutions and also the efforts via the league to increaseenforcement of strategies governing illegal hits to the head, this kind of as fines of upto $75,000.
"It's really apparent that donning a helmet, in and of itself, is not protectingour men from concussions too as other trauma," described Anderson, who can make initialdecisions on punishment for NFL safety-rule violations, "so to the extent thatwe can perform substantially more by aggressively enforcing our strategies and acquiring illegaltechniques and hits to the mind out using the game, we've an obligation to dothat."
The NFL and NFLPA concussion committees, helmet makers, the division ofDefense and leading experts will participate in discussions Dec. 8-9 to:examine whether or not one can find new supplies that could improve helmets; establish ifsensors need being utilized in helmets, mouthguards or earpieces donned by NFL playersto measure results of various types of hits to the head; evaluation the NFL'sreturn-to-play strategies founded in December 2009, this kind of as consideringwhether sideline checks used to establish if a player carries a concussion need to bestandardized so just about every group employs the same, mandated neurological exam.
"We're turning all over just about every stone you might imagine," described RichardEllenbogen, chairman using the school of Washington health care school's departmentof neurological surgical methods and co-chair using the NFL's head, neck and spine medicalcommittee.
The NFL states it's obtained invested $10 , 000, 000 on the concern contemplating about 2006, including$6 , 000, 000 on concussion- and helmet-related exploration and education.
"We certainly will not acquire a helmet that decreases concussions," described ThomMayer, health care director for that players' union, "unless we try."
The helmet makers say they are trying.
Boston University's Cantu quickly rattled away developments this kind of as Riddell'sincreased width, Schutt's new cushioning materials, and what he called Xenith's"rather dramatic" change from typical foams to air-cell padding insidehelmets.
No make a difference what breakthroughs have are available about, some NFL players soundskeptical about just just how much safeguard helmets can provide.
"They're generating tons of several designs of helmets, and I put on the old,traditional style. I kind of feel, like, if you are title to get knocked out,you're title to get knocked out," Indianapolis Colts cornerback Jerraud Powers(notes)said. "I do not actually believe the helmet issues when it arrives for you owning aconcussion or not."
described Pittsburgh Steelers protection Troy Polamalu(notes): "I've noticed players try outthe new helmets, get concussions and say, ‘I'm title back once more to the old one."'
just about every player is permitted to pick which brand he wears. The NFL estimatesthat 75 percent of helmets used this year or so are created by Riddell, which has experienced alicensing/sponsorship agreement using the league contemplating about 1990; 23 percent are madeby Schutt, 1 to some few of percent by Xenith, including a handful by Adams USA. Rawlings, whichstopped generating hockey helmets substantially greater than two decades ago, is returning to thebusiness in 2011 and has partnered using the Cleveland Clinic for concussionresearch.
based on Schutt, Eagles expert Bowler Jackson experienced been donning one certain of itshelmet versions that went faraway from development about two many years ago. Then came Oct.17, a Sunday filled with some especially vicious hits across the NFL,including the shot Jackson took from Atlanta Falcons cornerback Dunta Robinson(notes)that still left both males on the ground, motionless. Jackson and Robinson both ended upwith concussions; just about every missed his team's up arriving game; Robinson appealed the$50,000 good levied via the league for that hit.
D.J. MacLean, Schutt's director of sporting activities marketing, traveled toPhiladelphia final 1 week to examine on Jackson and his new helmet—outfitted,unlike his old Schutt, owning a materials the organisation states does a much better jobof withstanding impacts.
"A great offer substantially more cushioning. It felt good," Jackson described Friday following practice."I'll surely utilize it again."
Still, MacLean will almost certainly be the 1st to inform you, that materials cannot ensurethose effects do not cause concussions.
